Did anyone else notice this in Harry Potter?

7 replies [Last post]
meganobr
Online
Chief
Joined: 08/03/2016

So I posted a while back about the Chamber of Secrets, and a question I had. Now I'm rewatching The Goblet of Fire. Wizards write on parchment, right? In the books as well as the movies. But when Harry's name comes out of the Goblet, it's written on college ruled Muggle notebook paper!!! Anyone else agree with that being a giant screwup by the movie people?

EmeraldDragon03's picture
EmeraldDragon03
Offline
Supreme Viking Champion
Joined: 04/11/2017
yeah

yeah. also this

Image result for harry's name in the goblet of fire

__________________

My Signature

 

About Me:

 

 

Name: Taliah

Gender: Female

Species: Not really sure to be honest

Birthday: 28th of September

Lives In: NSW, Australia

Hobbies: Drawing, Reading, Playing Games, Watching TV, Riding Horses

Loves: Animals, Books, Drawing, Friends, Family

Hates: Abusive People, Avocados, Bugs, Heights, Small Spaces

Favourite Colour: Light Blue

Favourite Animals: Dragons, Horses, Wolves, Eagles, Owls

Favourite Dragon: Woolly Howl

Favourite Dog: Husky

Favourite Cat: Birman

Favourite Movies/Books: Harry Potter, How to Train Your Dragon, Eragon (Inheritance)

 

My Dragons:

 

Sapphire

(Titan)

Gender: Female

Species: Deadly Nadder

Colours: Dark Blue with Light Blue Belly

Personality: Adventurous, Confident, Loyal

Bond Level: 10/10

 

Nightshard

Gender: Female

Species: Razorwhip

Colours: Silver with Darkish Tinge

Personality: Cheerful, Daring, Friendly

Bond Level: 9.5/10

 

Shockwave

Gender: Male

Species: Thunderdrum

Colours: Green with Lighter Belly and Spots

Personality: Cooperative, Introverted, Quiet

Bond Level: 6.5/10

 

Coral

Gender: Female

Species: Tide Glider

Colours: Dark Blue with Light Blue Details and Pink Patterns

Personality: Bubbly, Playful, Sweet

Bond Level: 7.5/10

 

Cinder

Gender: Male

Species: Monstrous Nightmare

Colours: Orange with Darker Patterns and Yellow Belly

Personality: Athletic, Daring, Feisty

Bond Level: 7/10

 

Pebbles

Gender: Male

Species: Gronkle

Colours: Brown with Light Belly and Blue Speckles

Personality: Calm, Helpful, Lazy

Bond Level: 6.5/10

 

Sahara

Gender: Female

Species: Sand Wraith

Colours: Light Sandy Colour with Lighter Belly and Spots

Personality: Alert, Cheeky, Fun Loving

Bond Level: 8.5/10

 

Clouchaser

Gender: Male

Species: Stormcutter

Colours: Dark Blue with Light Blue Details

Personality: Dignified, Tolerent, Wise

Bond Level: 7.5/10

 

Firework

Gender: Male

Species: Typhoomerang

Colours: Blue with White Head and Light Blue Details

Personality: Optimistic, Stubborn, Competitive

Bond Level: 7/10

 

Shrubb

Gender: Female

Species: Prickleboggle

Colours:Green with Light Belly and Brown Spots

Personality: Easily Distracted, Energetic, Playful

Bond Level: 6/10

 

Geode

Gender: Male

Species: Snafflefang

Colours: Purple with Teal Patches and Light Blue Belly

Personality: Careless, Ordinary, Quiet

Bond Level: 5.5/10

 

Frostclaw

Gender: Male

Species: Groncicle

Colours: Light Icy Blue

Personality: Assertive, Greedy, Dignified

Bond Level: 6/10

 

Melody and Harmony

Gender: Female

Species: Zippleback

Colours: Purple with Light Blue Belly and Green Spots

Personality: Curious, Humerous, Imaginative

Bond Level: 5.5/10

 

Emberwing

Gender: Female

Species: Fireworm Queen

Colours: Gold with Light Belly and Dark Orange Spots

Personality: Competitive, Obedient, Tough

Bond Level: 6.5/10

 

Thistletail

Gender: Male

Species: Whispering Death

Colours: Dark Teal with Light Teal Belly and Greek Spines

Personality: Introverted, Quiet, Shy

Bond Level: 6/10

 

Lumpy

Gender: Male

Species: Hotburple

Colours: Brown with Lighter Belly and Spots

Personality: Calm, Gentle, Lazy

Bond Level: 6.5/10

 

Honeydew

Gender: Female

Species: Sweet Death

Colours: Light Brown with Light Green Wings

Personality: Friendly, Misunderstood, Sweet

Bond Level: 5/10

 

Quicksilver

Gender: Female

Species: Speed Stinger

Colours: Very Pale Teal with Light Belly and Darker Head Fin

Personality: Energetic, Fun Loving, Lovable

Bond Level: 7.5/10

 

Whiplash

Gender: Male

Species: Grapple Grounder

Colours: Light Bluw with Royal Blue Patterns and Light Belly

Personality: Clumsy, Humerous, Excluded

Bond Level: 6/10

 

Amazon

Gender: Male

Species: Raincutter

Colours: Green with Lighter Spots and Blue on Head and Back Fins and on Wings

Personality: Careless, Ordinary, Playful

Bond Level: 4.5/10

 

Avalanche

Gender: Male

Species: Woolly Howl

Colours: White with Pale Blue belly And Light Blue Fur

Personality: Funny, Loyal, Protective

Bond Level: 10/10

 

Seed, Stem, Leaf and Petal

Gender: Female

Species: Snaptrapper

Colours: Light Purple-Pink with Green Belly and Yellow Spots

Personality: Seed:Shy, Stem:Intelligent Leaf:Sweet Petal:Self Centred

Bond Level: 6.5/10

 

Silhouette

Gender: Male

Species: Skrill

Colours: Dark Purple with Lighter Details and Pale Lilac Belly

Personality: Brave, Sly, Witty

Bond Level: 7/10

 

Toothless

Gender: Male

Species: Night Fury

Colours: Black 

Personality: Funny, Loyal, Protective

Bond Level: 8/10

 

Blitz

Gender: Male

Species: Shockjaw

Colours: Light Blue with Green Belly and Back Sail and Dark Blue on Wings and Chin

Personality: Charming, Humerous, Joyful

Bond Level: 7.5/10

 

Desertsong

Gender: Male

Species: Moldruffle

Colours: Defult

Personality: Cheeky, Cute, Playful

Bond Level: 6/10

 

Atlas

Gender: Male

Species: Hobblegrunt

Colours: Different Shades of Light Teal

Personality: Cheerful, Playful, Naive

Bond Level: 5.5/10

 

Neptune

Gender: Male

Species: Scauldron

Colours: Dark Blue with Lighter Blue Belly and Details

Personality: Calm, Friendly, Proud

Bond Level: 8/10

 

Chorus

Gender: Female

Species: Deathsong

Colours: Purple with Light Belly and Blue Patterns

Personality: Adventurous, Curious, Daring

Bond Level: 8/10

 

Ignatius

Gender: Male

Species: Singetail

Colours: Orange with Yellow Details

Personality: Alert, Heroic, Masculine 

Bond Level: 6.5/10

 

Magmajaw

Gender: Male

Species: Eruptodon

Colours: Brown with Grey Underside and Deep Orange Details

Personality: Calm, Gentle, Shy

Bond Level: 6.5/10

 

Sherbet

Gender: Female

Species: Flame Whipper

Colours: Pale Yellow Head and Tail, Pink Body an Black Stripes

Personality: Cheerful, Energetic, Witty

Bond Level: 7/10

 

Flintfang

Gender: Male

Species: Armorwing

Colours: Pale Yellow with Black Stripes, Horns and Claws

Personality: Loyal, Protective, Shy

Bond Level: 6/10

 

Boreas

Gender: Male

Species: Snow Wraith

Colours: White with Blue Spots

Personality: Adventurous, Introverted, Lovable,

Bond Level: 7/10

 

Arrow

Gender: Male

Species: Boneknapper

Colours: White

Personality: Cheerful, Clever, Playful

Bond Level: 6.5/10

 

Pineheart

Gender: Male

Species: Timberjack

Colours: Darkish Brown with Dark Green Wing and Horn Tips

Personality: Alert, Corageous, Wise

Bond Level: 7/10

 

Azula

Gender: Female

Species: Flightare

Colours: Aqua with Lighter Aqua belly and Dark Blue Patterns

Personality: Elegant, Gentle, Mysterious

Bond Level: 7/10

 

Tempest

Gender: Female

Species: Triple Stryke

Colours: Dark Navy Blue with Blue Underside and Lighter Blue Details

Personality: Adventurous, Energetic, Protective

Bond Level: 8/10

 

Wynta

Gender: Female

Species: Woolly Howl

Colours: Light Blue with Darker Blue Fur and Blue Belly

Personality: Kind, Quiet, Shy

Bond Level: 9/10

 

Copper

Gender: Male

Species: Razorwhip

Colours: Copper

Personality: Calm, Friendly, Sweet

Bond Level: 7.5/10

 

Bramble

Gender: Male

Species: Deadly Nadder

Colours: Dark Teal with Light Green Belly and Light Spines

Personality: Adventurous, Curious, Easily Distracted

Bond Level: 5.5/10

 

Kelda

Gender: Female

Species: Mudraker

Colours: Light Purple with Dark Blue Spots and Aqua Belly and Sail

Personality: To be written

Bond Level: 6/10

 

Wavebreakee

Gender: Male

Species: Winndwalker

Colours: Dark Blue with Darker Blue Spots and Green Spine

Personality: (To Be Written)

Bond Level: 8.5/10

 

 

Favourite Classes: Sharp, Tidal and Strike

Goals in Game: Save up gems, collect one of every dragon, become #1 Ultimate Dragon Trainer

Friend Code: ELQIFI

 

It's Art Time!

 

Sapphire

By Werewolfgirl1253

 

Sapphire

By Dark Witch 11

 

Sapphire

By FloofQueen

 

Sapphire

By GreenAsSin

 

Nightshard

By Lululu6161

 

Sahara

By glorybringer

 

Firework

By Zikta

 

Lumpy

By DuskDaybreak

 

Quicksilver

By ShiroKageFox

 

Avalanche

By Wutend Bonfire

 

Avalanche

By FireNightStar

 

Avalanche

By BoomBox74

 

 

Wynta

By Alexadragonfire

 

 

Thank you to all those people who have done art and edits for me! Very much appreciated! <3

 

Drawings by Me (Not all of them, obviously)

(Feel free to request by PM-ing me)

 

Congrats if you read all that, I spent way more time on it than I should have. Nonetheless, hope you enjoyed it! :)

 

Paxy Romana's picture
Paxy Romana
Offline
Berk's Power Player
Joined: 07/30/2014
Yeup

Yeah there were... a lot of "creative" decisions in that movie. And honestly the paper, the muggle clothes, and the angry dumbledore thing all detracted from the feel in my opinion. I know they wanted it to feel more serious and relatable with Harry going through a tough patch, but it kinda felt like it drained some of the charm to me.

__________________

"Never be certain of anything - it's a sign of weakness." ~ Fourth Doctor

Liljatyna the albino flame whipper, my main dragon, inspired by my gecko.

BrickBellows the Moldruffle art by ScarfyWings

Brickbellows art by ScarfyWings

 and more not yet pictured here

Gronckle the Cryaotic, main dragon of Arvid and an original species (and art) by Chameishida.
Read his story here

Lilja by the great Arrowalker

Lilja & Kas by ScarfyWings

 

Njall and Lilja by FloofQueen!

Kas by Redwind

 Lilja by ShiroKageFox

meganobr
Online
Chief
Joined: 08/03/2016
You're not kidding!

Yeah, the muggle clothes that they all wear is aggravating. The books NEVER refer to the students wearing anything other than robes or PJs at Hogwarts. Sometimes outside school of course, to blend in, but never there.

And they lost a ton of charm by leaving Dobby and Winky out too. Especially how excited Dobby was to help save Harry's.... Oh!!! What did he call Ron? Please someone answer me! This'll drive me nuts all night. And I don't want to have to dig out the Goblet book.

GreenAsSin's picture
GreenAsSin
Offline
Supreme Viking Champion
Joined: 07/23/2014
"His Wheezy"

"His Wheezy"

__________________

                                  

 

The Bruiser Babes

 

Bi Pride!

 

 

Nadders made by Rae Diggeridoo, trainer ID created by Raziel Razgriz

Pride Flag Class Symbol and SC banner made by me

meganobr
Online
Chief
Joined: 08/03/2016
Ohhhh....

Thank you soooooooooooooo much! Please don't be offended, cus I know some people can get sorta upset about comments like this, but I'mma gonna say it anyway.

God bless you!!!

DragonLover43's picture
DragonLover43
Offline
Supreme Viking Champion
Joined: 05/15/2014
When I read the books I got

When I read the books I got the impression of "Loving old grandfather" from Dumbledore, and when he asked Harry if he'd put his name in it was in one of those "Tell me the truth. You're not in trouble if you're honest with me. I won't be angry, just disappointed" tones. Anyone else get that vibe? There's actually a great review of the books by a guy named "The Dom" on Youtube. Be warned, he's...passionate and can be quite vulgar if he's particularly upset about a change or paraphrasing quite heavily.

__________________

Proud leader of The Outliers!

There will be a link below of HTTYD 2 put to the song Centuries (Fall Out Boys). It's a condensed version of the whole movie and worth the watch.

Events!

Big Update Scavenger Hunt. Hints dropped daily.

Speed Stinger Race Track Idea!

Use this link to share your support and feedback! Let's make it possible to race on Speed Stingers!

 

Check out my fan fics

-Big Challenges (Finished. Please Comment, and read the sequel as well!)

-A Hidden Life (Sequel to Big Challenges.)

-Last and First

-First Generation (Daughter of Hiccup and Astrid)

-Great Ocean Gems

-A World of Discoveries

-Being Me

-The Black Cowl (Also a roleplay. PM me if you wish to join.)

-Twice the Twins, Twice the Fun

-The Dragonsblood Curse (With special thanks to Scensoredearchers) 

-First Friends 

-Last Remnant

-A Different Angle (A Big Hero 6 fan fic)

-Living a Lie 

-Middle (A Big Hero 6 Fan Fic)

-Welcome to Our Family 

-April Heist (A Big Hero 6 Fan Fic. Graphic Description. Reader's Discretion Advised.)

-A Cyber Kitty Named Wisdom (A Big Hero 6 Fan Fic)

- Gobber's Daughter 

- Adventurous Appreciation

- Bond Between

Please comment and give feedback on them. I value your opinion.

I'm moving some of my fan fictions over to Wattpad. Here's a link to my profile.

Also, if you like reading fan fiction. Please join the Fan Fiction Club

I also have a blog for my fan fic character. Link is at the bottom of my signature (Only available to those living in the United States and Canada. Sorry.)

My favorite reads:

Toothless' Kingdom (Dragonmic14), http://forum.schoolofdragons.com/content/toothlesss-kingdom

Hiccup and Astrid: A Family at Last! (NightFuryLover)

 

Also, if you'd like an uncensored version of my fanfictions, here's the link to Bond Between on Wattpad

 

Link I promised about the condensed version of HTTYD 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JJ8T2-p0W9s

If you see a hacker, you can report them here:

http://forum.schoolofdragons.com/content/sod-hack-watch-if-you-see-hacking-report-it-here

http://forum.schoolofdragons.com/content/sod-anti-hacking-team-open-all-forum-users

 

Spiker. (Whispering Death bouncie courtesy of Hattori!)

(Gronckle edits by Skypeoplephoenix.)

Here's a little side project I was almost finished. I just need to get the racing banners I recently lost due to a glitch back so I can complete it.

I recently created a blog for Nina, so if you're interested, here's the link: http://ninahaddocklife.blogspot.ca

Here are my adopted dragons.

Noche, from Smidvarg's Night Terrors. Thanks snowflake!

GreenAsSin's picture
GreenAsSin
Offline
Supreme Viking Champion
Joined: 07/23/2014
There are so, so many changes

There are so, so many changes between the book and the movies. You could comb through the two and list them for hours.

 

Ever since the train wreck that was Queen of the Damned I have long since stopped comparing films to their book counterparts in a critical way. Every now and again I bemoan the bigger changes, but I don't let myself get all worked up about it. It's saved me a lot of headaches and aggravation.

 

Now if only we could get someone to produce a Harry Potter series so we could get some more accurate screen time without the time limits that come attached to movies.